THE THREE OUTFLOWS
Crude oil, gold, and outbound tourism are India's three largest discretionary dollar drains. Together they account for the bulk of the current account deficit in any given year — which is why every Indian forex squeeze since 1991 has produced the same political ask.
WHY FUEL IS THE PERFECT TAX
Fuel is inelastic — people buy roughly the same amount regardless of price. India deliberately kept petrol and diesel outside the GST system, which lets the centre and states stack taxes independently. At peak in 2020, taxes comprised 65% of petrol's retail price.
THE GOLD PARADOX
Indian households hold an estimated 25,000 tonnes of gold — more than the combined official reserves of the US, Germany, IMF, and Italy. It is dead capital from a balance-of-payments view: bought with hard currency, locked in vaults and lockets, never circulating. Every wedding season is a quiet forex drain.
THE 1991 PRECEDENT
In July 1991, India airlifted 47 tonnes of central bank gold to the Bank of England as collateral for an emergency IMF loan. Reserves had collapsed to two weeks of import cover. The crisis forced the dismantling of the License Raj — Manmohan Singh's liberalisation. Modi's appeal echoes the rhetoric of that era without (yet) the underlying balance-of-payments emergency.
THE HORMUZ PASS-THROUGH
India imports about 85% of its crude. Roughly two-thirds of that crude transits the Strait of Hormuz. Any pricing-in of closure risk hits Indian retail prices within weeks — and the subsidy bill compounds faster than tax revenue can absorb.
WHY APPEALS TO RESTRAINT RARELY WORK
Voluntary consumption cuts are the weakest tool a government has. The 1973 oil shock prompted similar appeals across the developing world; almost none reduced demand measurably. Price signals (duty hikes, rationing) and quantity signals (import quotas) are the levers that actually move forex.